1. 27

  2. 9

    The issue of having to use undocumented functions is, unfortunately, not unusual in Erlang. OTP has accumulated a bunch of functions over the years and there are several functions in the standard library that are not exposed and yet are used.

    For example: lists:zf/2 eventually became lists:filtermap/2, but zf/2 is still exposed, although undocumented. Same with lists:rmerge/2 and lists:rmerge3/3—exposed but undocumented.

    With regards to using os:env/0, if you know the data won’t change, it’s recommended to pull it into your application environment (and use application:get_env/2 or similar) since that’s backed by an ETS table. Another option is to use persistent_term if it’s available in your OTP version, since it will allow you to read configuration data without copying any memory.

    1. 8

      I can see this causing trouble in certain environments. And article mentioned 90 env variables is even not that many. For example in a quite busy Kubernetes namespace I right now have pods that have not disabled enableServiceLinks in PodSpec and have ~700 env variables set (each Service gets bunch of env vars automatically set for every exposed port).

      1. 5

        This is exactly what happened to the application I mentioned in the post. Prior to migrating to Kubernetes I think this app was run in an environment with only a couple dozen variables. And after the move to Kubernetes I think we had around ~1200 set.

        1. 3

          I have been unamused with Elixir apps on Kubernetes and Docker, but here we are. :(

      2. 3

        This is great. On the one hand, it’s kind of silly that this was a problem. On the other hand, I 100% believe that Elixir has existed for almost a decade without someone serious writing performance-sensitive code that called System.get_env/0 dozens of times per request. Welcome to computers!

        1. 1

          I am surprised they don’t use pipelines in the stdlib.

          1. 1

            Not everywhere it is possible and if you have only single step pipeline then it is preferred to do just regular call instead of pipeline macro.