1. 11
  1.  

  2. 5

    I’ve worked a tiny bit on Eta, if anyone has questions.

    1. 3

      Definitely! What type of work was involved in porting essentially all of Haskell’s syntax to the JVM?

      1. 8

        GHC compiles through a few intermediate steps:

        1. Haskell source to GHC Core
        2. GHC Core to STG
        3. STG to Cmm
        4. Cmm to assembly

        GHC then provides a runtime, written in C which is linked into your program. Haskell libraries often have C FFI bindings, especially the core libraries.

        The work to port this to the JVM was:

        1. Swapping “STG to Cmm” with “STG to JVM bytecode”
        2. Porting GHC’s runtime to Java, while stubbing out some concurrency (for now)
        3. Rewriting C FFI calls into Java FFI calls

        Rahul Muttineni did 99% of this work and gave an awesome talk about what was involved:

        https://youtu.be/CscBSNF6qnE

      2. 3

        How’s interop with Java? The examples I found were clean, but also very short, proof-of-concept. How’s integration with some random Java library? With environments like Android?

        1. 5

          You can see the FFI is capable of even subtyping:

          https://github.com/typelead/eta-examples/blob/master/2-javafx/src/CalculatorApp.hs#L8-L9

          Which is pretty impressive - though I would probably avoid being in a situation where that’s useful.

          Here’s an example of writing a Minecraft mod:

          http://ncrashed.github.io/blog/posts/2016-10-22-ghcvm-minecraft-modding.html

          I’m not sure what has been tried with Android. I know Rahul wants to do some work for it. I don’t know if there’s anything currently stopping dx from translating from Eta’s .class output to .dx files.

          1. 2

            The calculator example was removed in a commit, so the first link is dead; it can be found here.

      3. [Comment removed by author]

        1. 4

          It’s not lost as soon as you involve Java. It means you can use all of GHC’s extensions and most of Hackage.

          1. 3

            I get it. Thanks for taking the time to answer my silly question instead of downvoting.