1. 16
  1.  

  2. 2

    Thanks for this write-up! I’d be curious to see just how many people are running MTA software as hidden services.

    1. 1

      No mask-source in the listen directive? I wonder what client IP address gets added to Received headers…

      1. 1

        The IP of the Tor-ified firewall:

        May  9 15:27:58 smtpd-01 smtpd[63268]: smtp-in: New session a2beaff0a42f673a from host 10.5.5.2 [10.5.5.2]
        May  9 15:28:02 smtpd-01 smtpd[63268]: smtp-in: Started TLS on session a2beaff0a42f673a: version=TLSv1.2, cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384, bits=256
        May  9 15:28:07 smtpd-01 smtpd[63268]: smtp-in: Accepted message 32a60c1b on session a2beaff0a42f673a: from=<shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion>, to=<shawn@mdz2craqs4gvefg5wbgwvc5rovlvh6tmanzoraykznm2wdrk5xqtsdid.onion>, size=1342, ndest=1, proto=ESMTP
        May  9 15:28:07 smtpd-01 smtpd[63268]: delivery: Ok for 32a60c1b3108639f: from=<shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion>, to=<shawn@mdz2craqs4gvefg5wbgwvc5rovlvh6tmanzoraykznm2wdrk5xqtsdid.onion>, user=shawn, method=maildir, delay=2s, stat=Delivered
        May  9 15:28:18 smtpd-01 smtpd[63268]: smtp-in: Closing session a2beaff0a42f673a
        

        So, everything’s still 100% anonymous.

        edit[0]: Here’s what the raw email looks like, with all the headers:

        Return-Path: <shawn@mdz2craqs4gvefg5wbgwvc5rovlvh6tmanzoraykznm2wdrk5xqtsdid.onion>
        Delivered-To: shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion
        Received: from smtpd-01 (192.168.254.2 [192.168.254.2])
        	by tormail-01 (OpenSMTPD) with ESMTP id ce94b548
        	for <shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion>;
        	Wed, 9 May 2018 11:28:17 -0400 (EDT)
        Received: from localhost (smtpd-01 [local])
        	by smtpd-01 (OpenSMTPD) with ESMTPA id 69a12445
        	for <shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion>;
        	Wed, 9 May 2018 15:27:21 +0000 (UTC)
        Date: Wed, 9 May 2018 15:27:20 +0000
        From: Shawn Webb <shawn@mdz2craqs4gvefg5wbgwvc5rovlvh6tmanzoraykznm2wdrk5xqtsdid.onion>
        To: shawn@3w2s7tpb5mc7ubsjjnzp4oxvqupjeoywzwdxfvfnjn3toqbuzgkn7kqd.onion
        Subject: Test of work MTA 01
        Message-ID: <20180509152720.thmkyagug6xk565o@smtpd-01>
        MIME-Version: 1.0
        Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
        Content-Disposition: inline
        User-Agent: NeoMutt/20180323
        
        This is a test of my work MTA 01.