1. 19
  1.  

  2. 8

    I’m very glad the conversation is about the quality of syntax highlighting, and not yet another “syntax highlighting sucks because I chose a particularly garish example to demonstrate this point”! More of that please!

    1. 7

      Jumping on the reduced-color theme bandwagon: For the last several years I’ve been using — and iteratively modifying —a theme called minimal-light. I’ve diverged far enough from the original that I renamed it:

      https://github.com/pzel/commentary-theme

      Like the original poster, I don’t yet have all of the myriad font-faces covered, but the theme does the job well enough for my own use.

      1. 2

        Nice one. Personally for my own taste I’d have probably formatted the comments a shade of gray, but red looks pretty nice too.

        For what it’s worth, this is what I’m currently using (screenshot) and I like it a lot, but sometimes it does feel too colorful. I might take your theme for a spin.

        1. 2

          Hah!, you see, the intense redness is the entire idea behind my theme. The original (which I can no longer find on the Internet) used the more common approach: there are 2 visual layers, and comments are in the less visible layer, greyed out.

          I find that putting comments in the visual background leads to programmers a) ignoring the comments that are already there; b) tolerating superfluous, lengthy comments.

          At a previous company, the ‘official’ code style policy involved huge comment blocks, which essentially included boilerplate easily found in the language manual, included in front of every function declaration. I figured one of the reasons people tolerated this bureaucracy is because they had comments ‘greyed out’ in their editors.

          1. 1

            Interesting! That’s actually a very good reason. Thanks for the explanation on your choice of color.

        2. 2

          That looks nice, thanks for posting it. Also, +1 for using Iosevka :)

        3. 3

          I definitely agree most themes highlight way too much. I’m using something like a stripped down gruvbox at the moment: http://imgur.com/a/sZaZP. I also highlight control structures though.

          1. 1

            I was not aware of gruvbox. I might migrate to it. I have been using material for a few years: http://imgur.com/a/fL30Q

          2. 2

            It’s hard to google for but I remember hearing about a language (ALGOL?) which specified a “typeset syntax.” Keywords are set in bold, identifiers in italic, etc. It seems that this could be a very readable sort of syntax highlighting as well.

            1. 2

              At first I scoffed, but actually I appreciate the thought he put into it. I’d say I’m convinced enough to give it a try for a week.

              1. 2

                Here’s a screenshot of my setup. I like to highlight just comments, literals (including strings), break/continue/return and references to key long-lived variables. In the screenshot, for example, highlighting caller_recipe helps to show that most of my logic just never cares about it. (It’s only needed for an error message deeper down the call stack.)

                To highlight specific variables I wrote this VimScript inspired by this demo.

                1. 1

                  It’d be interesting to have some sort of toggle-able highlighting where you can tell it to, for example:

                  • Highlight everything that can be highlighted (default)
                  • Highlight nothing
                  • Highlight only function names
                  • Highlight only variable names
                  • Highly only X (for whatever language construct X you’re interested in)
                  • Any combination of language constructs which can be individually highlighted
                    1. 1

                      I’d say the first example is far easier to concentrate on. Mainly because it’s, uh, not purple…

                      1. 2

                        Hah :) I wanted a darkish theme, but didn’t want blue or black. The channel bar in Slack got me thinking that maybe purple could work.

                        1. 1

                          each to his own then! :)

                          I might try making something like this for vim but with a black bg, I can’t really work with purple :shrug: